Keri Cronin


Leave a comment

“Do Not Refuse To Look At These Pictures”

The news about the abuse uncovered on an Ohio Dairy Farm by Mercy for Animals has hit the global media. The horrific film footage showing cows and calves being beaten, stabbed and kicked is stomach-turning.

I wish this were an isolated incident, but as anyone who has tried to learn more about where our food comes from knows all too well, abuse of animals in factory farm settings is not uncommon.

There is no doubt that this is difficult stuff to read about, look at, and discuss, but we need to know about it. I can’t tell you how many people have said to me “oh, I can’t look at that stuff. I can’t hear about animal abuse or look too hard into where my food comes from.” These are often well-educated, intelligent people who I love and respect. And yet on this point I must respectfully disagree. If you care about your health, the health of your family, about animals or the fate of our planet nothing could be more important than knowing these sorts of “dirty little secrets” that the factory farming industry would rather we didn’t know.

I’m not saying we should all make a bowl of popcorn and sit down with the family to watch the Ohio dairy farm footage on the big screen TV. And yet, as Ed Burtynsky pointed out during an interview on CBC’s The Current yesterday, imagery is often what brings much needed attention to an issue. Burtynsky was not talking about the Ohio Dairy Farm case but, rather, about another horrific story, the BP Oil Spill in the Gulf of Mexico. The point, however, is valid in both instances.

As someone who teaches about and conducts research on visual culture, this point is one that I have spent a lot of time thinking about. Right now I’m doing a lot of work on 19th century animal welfare activism and, in particular, the use of imagery in that movement. The great 19th century reformer Frances Power Cobbe began one of her illustrated anti-vivisection pamphlets with the words: “Do Not Refuse to Look at These Pictures.” She went on to discuss why it was so important for people to see with their own eyes the ways in which animals were treated behind closed doors in medical laboratories. Cobbe recognized that most people would not be granted access to these labs (just as we aren’t easily granted access to factory farm complexes) and, as such, she strongly believed in the power of visual culture to convey this difficult information to a broader public.

Things haven’t changed that much since Cobbe’s day and here I’d like to repeat her plea — “do not refuse to look at these pictures.” We can not keep ignoring what is going on.


Leave a comment

The Professor is In(nocent)?

A colleague recently introduced me to the world of academic mysteries. I’d encountered some of these books from time to time before but had not really stopped to consider that there might be a whole sub-genre of sleuthing profs out there. I began with Joanne Dobson’s Karen Pelletier mysteries, but apparently there are many, many more out there just waiting to be devoured.


2 Comments

Animal Body Worlds

Gunther von Hagens has launched another sensational exhibition, Body Worlds of Animals. Like the original Body Worlds, this exhibition uses plastination to preserve and exhibit dead bodies. Unlike the original exhibition, however, these bodies belonged to nonhuman animals before they became part of this exhibit. (Although I do recall a horse being included in the original Body Worlds, however, the focus there was most decidedly on human anatomy.)

There are, apparently, a wide range of animal bodies included in this exhibition. According to The Telegraph, several of these animal bodies were donated to the exhibition by the Neunkirchen Zoo. Through this donation we are encouraged to keep gazing upon these animals for our own entertainment, education, and enlightenment, even after their death. Unlike the dead humans in the original Body Worlds, these animals did not (could not?) give consent for their bodies to be used in this manner any more than they gave their consent to have been put on display in the zoo in the first place.

On the website for this exhibition Dr. von Hagens states that: “The more the individual thinks about the fragility of his or her body, the more respectful he or she will become toward other people and animals. BODY WORLDS of ANIMALS makes a valuable contribution to animal welfare and to increased appreciation of endangered species. The exhibition strongly supports the educational mission of the zoo and animal welfare organizations.”

The argument, it appears, is that this exhibition makes viewers realize the “fragility” of their bodies and, in turn, this leads to a heightened sense of appreciation of other species. This is a pretty tenuous link, one that echoes numerous arguments that have been made in favour of public zoos and animal theme parks throughout their history. According to this line of thinking, seeing animals in captivity or as “performers” somehow will make humans better appreciate nonhuman animals. The abundance of animal cruelty cases, the extinction (or near-extinction) of species and the destruction of habitats seems to be evidence to the contrary. Further, the notion that continued exploitation of animal bodies somehow supports animal welfare initiatives is very troubling.

PS: Is the giraffe on the Body Worlds of Animals website blinking!?? How many different kinds of creepy is that? Compare this to the stoic-looking splash screen for the original Body Worlds, with its visual nod to the very serious business of science and technology. A dead, blinking giraffe? Really?!?


2 Comments

Never a Dull Moment!

This weekend brought wrestling artists, vegan pub food and the official kick-off to the Spring 2010 biking season. Never a dull moment around these parts!

First, the wrestling artists. On Thursday evening Rodman Hall Arts Centre hosted “The Main Event” which was billed as a “bone-crunching matchup” between Duncan MacDonald and Graeme Patterson. Many other artists and curators also got in the ring that evening, and MC David Fancy and referee Derek Knight were fan favourites as well.

The Main Event featuring Graeme Patterson and Duncan MacDonald

Wrestling artists and refereeing colleagues weren’t the only exciting things on the weekend calendar. On Saturday night a crew of St. Catharines-based vegetarians headed out to Brooklyn’s in Thorold. We’d been told that this rather regular-looking sports bar has a menu that is anything from regular — vegan pub fare!! It was such a novelty to actually be able to choose from a menu instead of selecting the only meat-free option by default. I had a delicious spicy “chicken” sandwich, a couple of my friends had a “meatball” sub and another ordered the falafel. All three of these dishes received hearty endorsements, and we certainly plan to head back to try other things on the menu. I wish other pubs would offer similar dishes!

And, finally, I got my beautiful little Electra bike out on the road this weekend. Yipee!! The wind was a bit chilly so I didn’t go for a long ride, but it was fun just to be back riding around town and I look forward to more cycling adventures this spring and summer.


Leave a comment

No Bikes?

So, I had a medical appointment today. It was at a new building, a place I’d not been to before. As I walked up to the front door I saw this sign:

Hmmm… I want to give this medical establishment the benefit of the doubt. I want to believe they mean no motorbikes or something similar.

Can a place that purports to support human health actually ban bikes? Is this for real?!?


Leave a comment

Jane’s Walk

I just heard about this weekend’s “Jane’s Walk” initiative (thanks CBC!) — I love this idea! Even though St. Catharines isn’t listed as an official participant (yet), I’m going to get out my walking shoes and my camera and explore my new adopted neighbourhood in downtown St. Catharines today.

Updated — photos from my walk.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.